How many of the former Confederate States will Obama win in the Presidential Election?
Settled as Obama wins only three of 11
Florida, North Carolina, Virginia
Background:>
Background: Just shows what a difference a 148 years can make. A Black candidate for President so soon after the Civil War.
But really, Obama does have a chance to win some of these Southern states, breaking the stranglehold the Republican Party has had on the South for most of the last 40+ years. Some are looking at Georgia as a possibility, Virginia has a good chance of going Democratic, and there are possibilities elsewhere as well. Mississippi and Louisiana just elected Democratic Congressmen in special elections to fill seats formerly safely held by Republicans for years.
So, how many of these former states of the Confederate States of America (Virginia, North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia, Florida, Alabama, Mississippi, Louisiana, Texas, Arkansas, and Tennessee) will Obama win the popular vote? Does not have to have a majority, just a plurality.
Settlement details:As reported by a major mainstream news source.
How many of the former Confederate States will Obama win in the Presidential Election?
Obama wins none of 11
Obama wins only one of 11
Obama wins only two of 11
Obama wins only three of 11
Obama wins only four of 11
Obama wins only five of 11
Obama wins only six of 11
Obama wins only seven of 11
Obama wins only eight of 11
Obama wins nine or more of 11
Zoom out
Forecast history %
|
| Obama wins none of 11 | |
|
| Obama wins only one of 11 | |
|
| Obama wins only two of 11 | |
|
| Obama wins only three of 11 | |
|
| Obama wins only four of 11 | |
|
| Obama wins only five of 11 | |
|
| Obama wins only six of 11 | |
|
| Obama wins only seven of 11 | |
|
| Obama wins only eight of 11 | |
|
| Obama wins nine or more of 11 | |
Settled as Obama wins only three of 11 on Thu 6th Nov 2008 2:52pm PST
Suspend date: Mon 3rd Nov 2008 11:59pm PST
Settlement date: Thu 6th Nov 2008 2:52pm PST
Prediction cut-off: Predictions on this question after Mon 3rd Nov 2008 11:59pm PST have been voided because they were made after the question could be settled
Initial likelihoods:
Obama wins none of 11 : 14%, Obama wins only one of 11 : 16%, Obama wins only two of 11 : 18%, Obama wins only three of 11 : 14%, Obama wins only four of 11 : 10%, Obama wins only five of 11 : 8%, Obama wins only six of 11 : 7%, Obama wins only seven of 11 : 6%, Obama wins only eight of 11 : 5%, Obama wins nine or more of 11 : 2%
Action history:
Suspended Mon 3rd Nov 2008 11:59pm PST : Suspend date reached
Settlement requested Thu 6th Nov 2008 2:40pm PST by
measure
:
I believe all these states have been called, and I believe the correct answer is three.
Settled as 'Obama wins only three of 11 ' Thu 6th Nov 2008 2:52pm PST by
destry![This user is an admin [Admin]](http://www.hubdub.com/images/icon_admin.gif)

:
Florida, North Carolina, Virginia
Suspend date: Mon 3rd Nov 2008 11:59pm PST
Settlement date: Thu 6th Nov 2008 2:52pm PST
Prediction cut-off: Predictions on this question after Mon 3rd Nov 2008 11:59pm PST have been voided because they were made after the question could be settled details
Predictions (473)
1 year ago
bgrigore
predicted
Obama wins only three of 11 (H$500 at 25%)
1 year ago
bgrigore
predicted
Obama wins none of 11 (H$300 at 7%)
1 year ago
bgrigore
predicted
Obama wins only one of 11 (H$300 at 9%)
1 year ago
charugan
predicted
Obama wins only four of 11 (H$480 at 22%)
1 year ago
charugan
predicted
Obama wins only three of 11 (H$171 at 33%)
Comments (7)
They're only giving obama an 8 percent shot at winning GA. Not great.
Trends and history put NC most likely with McCain, and Florida is a true toss-up, right down till all the votes are counted (and hopefully not thrown away like 8 years ago).
I see a lot of people predicting three when a look at the true odds of potential scenarios on realclearpolitics or fivethirtyeight would incline someone to predict two.
4 states and up total 38% - these options are impossible.
zero is at 5% - yet the aggregate chance of him losing VA, NC, and FL are less than 1%.
So, 43% of the predictions can be reasonably considered to be void, meaning there is a lot of money to be made guessing one right (1/2/3), or spreading it among those three and still banking a profit.
Please log in or join to add a comment