NFL - "Old men" vs "Young kids." Which pair of QB's will have a better season?
Settled as Rivers and Rogers have best QB rating
Week 16
Rivers 105.5
Rodgers 93.8
"Young kids" = 99.65
Warner 96.9
Favre 81
"Old men" = 88.95
Background:>
Last summer, Kurt Warner wondered aloud if an old, grizzled quarterback with a graying beard could be the face of the Arizona Cardinals. Now we’re left to ponder whether he can be the face of the NFL. (at the old age of 37)
Warner back to MVP form
Meanwhile, we all know the story of the oldest QB in the NFL, who came out of retirement to play for the Jets. (at the age of 39).
After 11 weeks, these 2 "old men" are #1 and #6 in QB ratings.
Currently ranked #2 and #5 are the "young kids" Philip Rivers (age 26) and Aaron Rogers (age 24).
Quarterback ratings
Question is asking which pair will have the better QB rating (by average of the 2).
Current ratings:
Kurt Waner 105.5
Brett Favre 93
Avg = 99.25
Philip Rivers 100.8
Aaron Rogers 94.5
Avg = 97.65
Settlement details:
As reported by a major mainstream news source.
NFL - "Old men" vs "Young kids." Which pair of QB's will have a better season?
Warner and Favre have best QB rating
Rivers and Rogers have best QB rating
Exact tie
Zoom out
Forecast history, %
Settled
|
| Warner and Favre have best QB rating | |
|
| Rivers and Rogers have best QB rating | |
|
| Exact tie | |
Activity: H$19,670
Settled as
Rivers and Rogers have best QB rating on Mon 29th Dec 2008 7:36am PST
Suspend date: Sun 21st Dec 2008 10am PST Settlement date: Mon 29th Dec 2008 7:36am PSTPrediction cut-off: Predictions on this question after Sun 21st Dec 2008 10am PST have been voided because they were made after the question could be settled
Initial likelihoods:
Warner and Favre have best QB rating: 50%, Rivers and Rogers have best QB rating: 45%, Exact tie: 5%
Action history:
Suspended Sun 21st Dec 2008 10am PST : Suspend date reached
Settled as 'Rivers and Rogers have best QB rating' Mon 29th Dec 2008 7:36am PST by
mrperfkt![This user is an admin [Admin]](http://www.hubdub.com/images/icon_admin.gif)

:
Week 16
Rivers 105.5
Rodgers 93.8
"Young kids" = 99.65
Warner 96.9
Favre 81
"Old men" = 88.95
Suspend date: Sun 21st Dec 2008 10am PST Settlement date: Mon 29th Dec 2008 7:36am PSTPrediction cut-off: Predictions on this question after Sun 21st Dec 2008 10am PST have been voided because they were made after the question could be settled
more info...
Predictions (57)
57 predictions
2 weeks ago
lcsnor
predicted
Rivers and Rogers have best QB rating (H$75 at 70%)
2 weeks ago
ihydsqrl
predicted
Rivers and Rogers have best QB rating (H$1,000 at 67%)
3 weeks ago
lcsnor
predicted
Rivers and Rogers have best QB rating (H$75 at 54%)
3 weeks ago
coolkraft
predicted
Warner and Favre have best QB rating (H$100 at 36%)
3 weeks ago
gtown
predicted
Rivers and Rogers have best QB rating (H$30 at 64%)
more2 weeks ago
lcsnor
predicted
Rivers and Rogers have best QB rating (H$75 at 70%)
2 weeks ago
ihydsqrl
predicted
Rivers and Rogers have best QB rating (H$1,000 at 67%)
3 weeks ago
lcsnor
predicted
Rivers and Rogers have best QB rating (H$75 at 54%)
3 weeks ago
coolkraft
predicted
Warner and Favre have best QB rating (H$100 at 36%)
3 weeks ago
gtown
predicted
Rivers and Rogers have best QB rating (H$30 at 64%)
3 weeks ago
gtown
predicted
Rivers and Rogers have best QB rating (H$50 at 63%)
3 weeks ago
gtown
predicted
Rivers and Rogers have best QB rating (H$50 at 63%)
3 weeks ago
philphan1
predicted
Warner and Favre have best QB rating (H$20 at 36%)
4 weeks ago
gtown
predicted
Rivers and Rogers have best QB rating (H$50 at 58%)
4 weeks ago
zimm001
predicted
Warner and Favre have best QB rating (H$100 at 40%)
4 weeks ago
vtotter4
predicted
Rivers and Rogers have best QB rating (H$500 at 55%)
4 weeks ago
vtotter4
predicted
Rivers and Rogers have best QB rating (H$500 at 50%)
4 weeks ago
aland
predicted
Exact tie (H$20 at 2%)
5 weeks ago
gtown
predicted
Rivers and Rogers have best QB rating (H$20 at 48%)
5 weeks ago
mrperfkt![This user is an admin [Admin]](http://www.hubdub.com/images/icon_admin.gif)

predicted
Rivers and Rogers have best QB rating (H$1,000 at 42%)
5 weeks ago
vtotter4
predicted
Rivers and Rogers have best QB rating (H$100 at 36%)
5 weeks ago
vtotter4
predicted
Rivers and Rogers have best QB rating (H$100 at 35%)
6 weeks ago
vtotter4
predicted
Rivers and Rogers have best QB rating (H$300 at 31%)
6 weeks ago
coolkraft
predicted
Warner and Favre have best QB rating (H$250 at 68%)
Showing recent public predictions only
less
Comments (23)
Warner and Favre both have tough games this weekend.
Warner 102.4
Favre 94.1
Old Guys Avg = 98.25
Rivers 103.3
Rodgers 90.5
Young Kids Avg = 96.9
Rivers 100.5
Rodgers 91.2
young kids avg: 95.85
Warner 99.4
Farve 90.4
old guys avg: 94.9
What happened to the "lock to win?" :)
This is going to be close!
Thanks for creating such a clever question indeed.
Rivers - 102
Rodgers - 92.1
"Young Kids" = 97.05
Warner - 99.1
Favre - 88.2
"Old men" = 93.65
http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/stats/byposition?pos=QB
The old men have a rough week!
Rivers - 101.4
Rodgers - 91.8
"Young kids" = 96.6
Warner - 97.5
Favre - 86.5
"Old men" = 92
The Jets appear to have the easiest game this week against the struggling Seahawks. Can Favre pull the Old Men's average up?!
Rivers 105.5
Rodgers 93.8
"Young kids" = 99.65
Warner 96.9
Favre 81
"Old men" = 88.95
Please log in or join to add a comment