Net worth: H$1,000
Guest:Cash: hd$1,000   Predictions: hd$0
You currently have hd$1,000 (Hubdub dollars), Hubdub's virtual currency, to stake on your predictions. Your predictions are currently worth hd$0
Home
Leaderboards
Forums
PoliticsSportEntertainmentWorldBusinessTechnologyScienceGeneral

When will the first Atlantic tropical storm / hurricane of 2009 be named?

Settled as August 1st - August 15th

TD2 became Tropical Storm Ana as of the 8/15 5:00 AM update, which was released via Public Advisory 13 at 4:47AM EDT

http://www.nhc.noaa.gov/archive/2009/al02/al022009.public.013.shtml?

Background:

Background: The official start of the Atlantic hurricane season is June 1st. However, storms have formed far before that, with the earliest in the Atlantic appearing on February 2, 1952, and some--such as 1992's devastating Andrew--not popping up until near the end of August.

The question here, then, is this: in which date range will the first Atlantic tropical storm and/or hurricane of 2009 be named? (The name, by the way, will be 'Ana'.)

Note that storms are named by the National Hurricane Center in Miami when winds near the center reach a sustained 39mph.

Note, too, that we're looking for 2009 storms exclusively. If a storm is named near the end of December 2008 and then lives into 2009--something which has happened twice before--it won't count; THE STORM MUST BE OFFICIALLY NAMED IN 2009!

(I'm using my best judgment in setting the initial odds. If anyone thinks they're highly unrealistic, please let me know.)

Settlement details:As reported by the National Hurricane Center in Miami

 
Forecast history %
On or before April 30
0%
May 1st - May 15th
0%
May 16th - May 31st
0%
June 1st - June 15th
0%
June 16th - June 30th
0%
July 1st - July 15th
0%
July 16th - July 31st
0%
August 1st - August 15th
100%
August 16th - August 31st
0%
On or after September 1st
0%
Settled as August 1st - August 15th on Sat 15th Aug 2:24am PST

Suspend date: Mon 30th Nov 11:59pm PST (1 week to go)
Settlement date: Sat 15th Aug 2:24am PST
Prediction cut-off: Predictions on this question after Sat 15th Aug 12:45am PST have been voided because they were made after the question could be settled

Initial likelihoods: On or before April 30: 1%, May 1st - May 15th: 4%, May 16th - May 31st: 8%, June 1st - June 15th: 9%, June 16th - June 30th: 11%, July 1st - July 15th: 13%, July 16th - July 31st: 20%, August 1st - August 15th: 22%, August 16th - August 31st: 10%, On or after September 1st: 2%

Action history:

Created Mon 22nd Dec 2008 8:01am PST by sqlman[Admin]
Settlement requested Mon 18th May 5:51am PST by horsefeathers: http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,270968,00.html
Settlement requested Tue 23rd Jun 3:15pm PST by horsefeathers: it was named Andres - news from yesterday - June 22:
http://www.thedailygreen.com/environmental-news/latest/tropical-storm-andres-47061901
Settlement requested Sat 27th Jun 6:02pm PST by horsefeathers: I have written in 3 times with the answer: Andres was designated the first storm of 2009 on June 22:
http://www.tcpalm.com/news/2009/jun/22/first-named-storm-forms-mexicos-pacific-coast/

I have not heard anything. Please reply and settle. Thanks
Suspended Sun 28th Jun 12:22pm PST by mork[Power User]: Suspended pending settlement
Settlement requested Sun 28th Jun 12:22pm PST by mork[Power User]: [A/S] Flag count reset last Monday 11:59pm EDT by destry[Admin] [Level 17, Superdubber (H$1,992,278)] : was 1
Settlement requested last Tuesday 7:15pm EDT by horsefeathers [Level 12, Guru (H$32,896)] : it was named Andres - news from yesterday - June 22:
http://www.thedailygreen.com/environmental-news/latest/tropical-storm-andres-47061901 (market suspended)
Unsuspended Sun 28th Jun 2:38pm PST by destry[Admin]: Market suspended incorrectly.
Suspended Sat 15th Aug 2:18am PST by sqlman[Admin]: Suspended pending settlement
Settlement requested Sat 15th Aug 2:18am PST by sqlman[Admin]: TD2 became Tropical Storm Ana as of the 5:00 AM update, which was released via Public Advisory 13 at 4:47AM EDT (It's not marked with the time, but that's what time it arrived in my inbox from the NHC. At the latest, it needs to close at 5:00AM.

http://www.nhc.noaa.gov/archive/2009/al02/al022009.public.013.shtml? (market suspended)
Settled as 'August 1st - August 15th' Sat 15th Aug 2:24am PST by sqlman[Admin]: TD2 became Tropical Storm Ana as of the 8/15 5:00 AM update, which was released via Public Advisory 13 at 4:47AM EDT

http://www.nhc.noaa.gov/archive/2009/al02/al022009.public.013.shtml?

Suspend date: Mon 30th Nov 11:59pm PST (1 week to go)
Settlement date: Sat 15th Aug 2:24am PST
Prediction cut-off: Predictions on this question after Sat 15th Aug 12:45am PST have been voided because they were made after the question could be settled details

 

Predictions (788)

14 weeks ago
alexanderr predicted August 16th - August 31st (H$393 at 3%)
14 weeks ago
martianman predicted On or after September 1st (H$300 at 2%)
14 weeks ago
martianman predicted August 16th - August 31st (H$750 at 38%)
14 weeks ago
destry[Admin] predicted August 1st - August 15th (H$1,000 at 46%)
14 weeks ago
frogchop predicted August 16th - August 31st (H$1,000 at 54%)

Comments (41)

  1 bobdevine
Good tracking website
http://www.nhc.noaa.gov/gtwo_atl.shtml

Nothing much happening 7/19.
posted 18 weeks ago
Look at the noaa map. See the large low pressure system forming on the African coast. The only question now is when will it get into range to become a named storm?
posted 15 weeks ago
  3 frogchop
Sorry, I just can't resist the pun at the moment, but that is one sad looking tropical depression.

D'oh!
posted 14 weeks ago
Whoa! Who slammed the 8/1-8/15 option up to 82% ?
posted 14 weeks ago
  5 cici
Not me, but Frog just talked me right back into the 8/16 8/31. Anyone remember Andrew or Charlie??? same time.
posted 14 weeks ago
  6 sqlman[Admin]
I dunno; looks like T.S. Ana will likely be born by morning. And cici? Charley was formed on August 9th, and became a hurricane on the 11th.
posted 14 weeks ago
don't count the chickens before they're hatched!
posted 14 weeks ago
looks like they're hatching...
posted 14 weeks ago
  9 cici
@Squig - living in the Vatican - All I know is they all come for my birthday, which is the 18th. TD2 may or may not become Ana but the one behind (I guess TD3) looks like definite trouble.
posted 14 weeks ago
  10 buckeyetom
This is a good question. It's like betting on two horses that are coming down the stretch and racing against the clock.
posted 14 weeks ago
  11 cici
We're remembering the 5th anniversary of Charley tomorrow. It's a good question Bucky, but our weatherman says they expect it to be Ana this afternoon or evening. It's not going to be anything (or so we say) but if it doesn't become a named storm today, it will be gone tomorrow. Down to the wire.
posted 14 weeks ago
looks like it fizzled....
posted 14 weeks ago
  13 frogchop
As I said before, it was one sad looking depression.
posted 14 weeks ago
  14 coolkraft
yep...on to the rest of August
posted 14 weeks ago
  15 cici
Wow, did everyone jump on next week. I didn't even get a chance to look at the maps yet.
posted 14 weeks ago
  16 buckeyetom
Read the new update. The cell closest to Africa is reforming with better than a 50% chance of becoming a cyclone.
posted 14 weeks ago
  17 jeopardy
OK - dumb question: is a "tropical cyclone" (the term used on the NOAA site), the same as a named "tropical storm"? That is, when a low becomes a "cyclone" it will be assigned a name? It appears that it is, but wanted to make sure. (P.S.: that's a pretty intense chart showing the developing odds!)
posted 14 weeks ago
they name a storm when the minimum wind speed passes a defined threshold hence the Safir Scale
posted 14 weeks ago
  19 sqlman[Admin]
@jeopardy: a tropical cyclone is any large-scale spinning tropical system with closed circulation and convection at the center. Such a tropical system both acquires a name and becomes a tropical storm when it has sustained winds of 39 mph or more at the center (and it becomes a hurricane when those winds reach 74 mph).

Yeah, 90L is looking pretty good on Meteosat-8 this afternoon, so it's got a great chance. However, 02L, which had been fizzling, is actually trying to stage a comeback with some pretty good convection around the center, though shear is pushing the storms away as soon as they grow. Still, it's hard to believe the winds aren't 39 mph yet; look at it on the RGB loop... Meanwhile, closer to home, the elongated system north of Haiti and the DR is having a pretty good flare-up of convection right now; it may even make it into something by tomorrow evening (though that's not really likely)...

(FWIW, the model consensus is that 90L will be at or near hurricane strength in the vicinity of Puerto Rico by next Thursday or so.)
posted 14 weeks ago
  20 frogchop
The site is using a mix of language that sounds pretty contradictory unless you look at their definitions section:
"A TROPICAL DEPRESSION COULD FORM FROM THIS SYSTEM DURING THE NEXT COUPLE OF
DAYS AS IT MOVES WESTWARD AT 10 TO 15 MPH. THERE IS A HIGH
CHANCE...GREATER THAN 50 PERCENT...OF THIS SYSTEM BECOMING A
TROPICAL CYCLONE DURING THE NEXT 48 HOURS."

Tropical Cyclone:
A warm-core non-frontal synoptic-scale cyclone, originating over tropical or subtropical waters, with organized deep convection and a closed surface wind circulation about a well-defined center. Once formed, a tropical cyclone is maintained by the extraction of heat energy from the ocean at high temperature and heat export at the low temperatures of the upper troposphere. In this they differ from extratropical cyclones, which derive their energy from horizontal temperature contrasts in the atmosphere (baroclinic effects).

Tropical Storm:
A tropical cyclone in which the maximum sustained surface wind speed (using the U.S. 1-minute average) ranges from 34 kt (39 mph or 63 km/hr) to 63 kt (73 mph or 118 km/hr).
posted 14 weeks ago
  21 frogchop
So, it could become more organized in the next 48 hours, but it will also be a couple days before it actually reaches tropical depression.

Tropical Depression:
A tropical cyclone in which the maximum sustained surface wind speed (using the U.S. 1-minute average) is 33 kt (38 mph or 62 km/hr) or less.
posted 14 weeks ago
It's all going to depend on the exact timing. Looks like the latest tropical wave has a good chance to become more organized, but with the El Nino winds shearing off the tops, these systems have been slow to develop and fast to dissipate. Ought to be fun, 'cause it'll probably be a close call either way.
Stay tuned!
posted 14 weeks ago
With all the fighting about August 15, I just picked up Sept at better than 1:100 odds. If this el Nino shearing wind aloft continues, it just may squash all the systems trying to develop. So far, it's won each time, so I'd say the odds are a lot better than 1:50 that we will make it through August without a TS!
posted 14 weeks ago
squlman, you are going all in with a weak hand, I might add. I'll take your odds!
posted 14 weeks ago
  25 cici
Frogy - don't get in a tizzy. We call them hurricanes here in the Atlantic. 39 mph winds gets a name,tropical storm Ana., 74 mph becomes a hurricane. hurricane Ana. Don't clutter things up with a lot of facts. Later we can get to 1-2-3-4-5.
This thing has been wandering with 35 mph. but watch that next one.
posted 14 weeks ago
  26 sqlman[Admin]
Every storm has its own timetable; one can meander along as a tropical depression for a week without ever reaching tropical storm strength, while the next can go from a tropical depression to a Category 3 hurricane in 24 hours or so. It all depends on a lot of factors: sea surface temperatures, wind shear, proximity of dry/cool air, and so on. I've seen tropical storms right on the verge of becoming a hurricane vanish--literally--overnight, with barely a remnant low to show for it. I've also seen little tropical disturbances come off of Africa and blossom into fully-developed Cape Verde-type storms in just a day or two. 90L is several hundred miles south of the dry air north of it, it's over water with SSTs of 27-28°C (plenty warm enough), and wind shear is expected to remain about 10-20 knots for the next several days. We'll have to see what tomorrow and Saturday bring.

Gonna be a nail-biter...
posted 14 weeks ago
  27 cici
@Destry, were you in Port Charlotte for Charley????
posted 14 weeks ago
  28 cici
For our 5 year anniversary of Charley, there were 11,000 buildings destroyed and 59,000 damaged.
posted 14 weeks ago
  29 coolkraft
@tuff...sure is worth a bet...agree with your analysis El Nino is helping us
posted 14 weeks ago
  30 destry[Admin]
Yes I was. I left the house i was renting and stayed with family just up the road in North Port. It was a good thing, the house I was renting had the roof and two walls knocked down during storm. There will be a celebration on August 15th in Punta Gorda showcasing how the area has recovered. Jeb Bush has agreed to appear.
posted 14 weeks ago
The clock is winding down, the race is on. Can this eastern-most system develop into a tropical storm in the next 36 hours? It's not even a tropical depression yet, though it may well develop into one later today. Then it has to make the next grade within 24 h or so. Place your bets, ladies and gentlemen, the race is ON!
posted 14 weeks ago
  32 sqlman[Admin]
@tuff_sledding: hardly all in; I'm sitting on a pretty nice-sized pile of chips. And I wouldn't say it's a weak hand...though (to really stretch the analogy) with Mother Nature dealing, you never know. Sometimes it's pocket rockets; next time it's rags. You know? ;-)
posted 14 weeks ago
  33 cici
@ Destry - Oh my, I don't want another that close again. When it started its eastern turn I thought for sure it was coming over Sanibel and straight up the Caloosahatche, and the end was near. I was alone in the center of my 1925 house, with glass breaking, and "stuff" hitting the house, and my niece in North Carolina calling and wanting my to go out & look so I could tell her what was happening. For me, it was not as bad as it sounded. My damage was minimal and I got paid more than fairly by Allstate.
posted 14 weeks ago
this is getting good! the pot has grown to nearly 390K.
I don't see any serious development so far, but there is still about 30 h to go. this may go down to the wire, to throw in another cliche....
Whatever pile of chips you have my friend sqlman, go ahead and throw it in, I still like my odds. :-)
The last update prior to August 16th will be tomorrow evening @ 8 PM. If it doesn't make TS status by then, it's not going to make it. Therefore, 26 h and counting.....
stay tuned.
PS, we need more markets like this! How about "when will the next hurricane form in the Atlantic?"
Or "how many named storms will there be in September?", etc..
posted 14 weeks ago
  35 sqlman[Admin]
No more serious developments? How about the remnant low TD2 was upgraded back to having a better than 50% chance of developing by tomorrow or so at the 8:00PM EDT update, and Invest 90L has an equal chance. The DVORAK numbers for both are looking better by the hour, and they both appear fairly robust on satellite presentations. It's possible (though admittedly not likely) that we may not just see T.S. Ana tomorrow, but T.S. Bill, as well.


Yes, you're right...mostly...that we have until 8:00PM EDT tomorrow; should it warrant it, the NHC sometimes put out intermediate advisories (11:00 AM & PM and 5:00 AM & PM). And if the NHC determines a storm crosses certain thresholds--say, when it becomes a storm, or when it becomes a major hurricane--they put out bulletins regardless of the time. IOW, this one needs to wait until midnight EDT before being called if nothing has happened by then...
So make those questions; I'll buy in!
posted 14 weeks ago
Well, the upgrade just happened a short while ago. My earlier post pre-dated that announcement.
So, the chances are improving that there will be at TD or two in the next 24h. But will they make it to TS strength by midnight tomorrow? Time will tell, as it always does...
PS, the pot's now over 410K! Pity it's not winner take all like in poker....
posted 14 weeks ago
  37 sqlman[Admin]
"But will they make it to TS strength by midnight tomorrow?"

I'm, er, betting on it. ;-)
posted 14 weeks ago
El Nino let me down. You win, congratulations. That was fun, win or loose. I think I will go and create those other questions. I salute the winner :-)
posted 14 weeks ago
  39 sqlman[Admin]
Yes, it was fun. Everyone likes a nail-biter, huh? :-)
posted 14 weeks ago
  40 cici
These things that happen while I'm asleep!!!
posted 14 weeks ago
  41 sqlman[Admin]
Yep, even a two-fer to drive home the point: TS Bill was born today, too, roughly 12 hours after Ana. The nursery is getting crowded all of a sudden...
posted 14 weeks ago

Please log in or join to add a comment

Stake virtual dollars on the outcomes of real news stories! Win more if you're right and climb the leaderboards Learn more...

Name
Email
New password
By joining you are agreeing to our terms of service

Related News
This news is selected automatically based on the question, its background, options and tags