Created Fri 23rd May 12:41am PDT by
chatarra
All questions » General » Litigation » Will Saudi judges overturn decision on Saudi couple accused of severely abusing their maid?
Current forecast: 11% chance

Combining all predictions, the current forecast is that this is 11% likely to happen (unchanged in last 1 day)
Human Rights Watch has called on Saudi judges to overturn a decision to drop charges against a Saudi couple accused of severely abusing an Indonesian maid. Ms Miyati, 25, contracted gangrene after allegedly being tied up for a month and left without food in 2005. She had to have several fingers and toes amputated. Human Rights Watch says Ms Miyati was treated in a Riyadh hospital in March 2005 for gangrene, malnourishment and other injuries.
All charges against Ms Miyati's male employer were dropped early in the investigation, Human Rights Watch says. A judge in Riyadh awarded $670 damages to the maid, Nour Miyati, but dropped all charges against her employers. On Monday a Riyadh judge found the female employer not guilty, despite her earlier admission and "compelling physical evidence", the group says.
A prior Saudi judgement, subsequently overturned, had seen Ms Miyati convicted of falsely accusing her employers and sentenced to 79 lashes. Human Rights Watch said the latest ruling "sends a dangerous message to Saudi employers that they can beat domestic workers with impunity and that victims have little hope of justice". Rights organizations say many foreign domestic maids in Saudi Arabia work in harsh circumstances and often suffer abuse by their employers.
The Saudi Labour Ministry has acknowledged some problems, but the government also says foreign workers' rights are protected under Islamic law.
Click here for more
And here's another story on it
All charges against Ms Miyati's male employer were dropped early in the investigation, Human Rights Watch says. A judge in Riyadh awarded $670 damages to the maid, Nour Miyati, but dropped all charges against her employers. On Monday a Riyadh judge found the female employer not guilty, despite her earlier admission and "compelling physical evidence", the group says.
A prior Saudi judgement, subsequently overturned, had seen Ms Miyati convicted of falsely accusing her employers and sentenced to 79 lashes. Human Rights Watch said the latest ruling "sends a dangerous message to Saudi employers that they can beat domestic workers with impunity and that victims have little hope of justice". Rights organizations say many foreign domestic maids in Saudi Arabia work in harsh circumstances and often suffer abuse by their employers.
The Saudi Labour Ministry has acknowledged some problems, but the government also says foreign workers' rights are protected under Islamic law.
Click here for more
And here's another story on it
Settlement details:
As reported by a major mainstream news source.
Additional settlement details may be found at
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/7415290.stm
http://hrw.org/english/docs/2008/05/21/saudia18914.htm
Make your prediction!
|
|
Yes |
|
|||
|
|
No |
|
Activity: H$377
Question suspends in 5 weeks
Suspend date: Wed 31st Dec 11:59pm PST (5 weeks to go)
Initial likelihoods: Yes: 10%
Action history:
Created Fri 23rd May 12:41am PDT by
chatarra
Suspend date: Wed 31st Dec 11:59pm PST (5 weeks to go)
more info...
Predictions (8)
8 predictions
Comments (6)
What is Hubdub?
Hubdub makes news more exciting by letting you stake virtual dollars on the outcomes of real running news stories.
Join now or learn moreRelated News
This news is selected automatically based on the question, its background, options and tags
This news is selected automatically based on the question, its background, options and tags
score: 10
Al Jazeera 1 week ago
George Bush, the US president, has challenged Saudi Arabia to overturn its ban on apostasy - the changing of a person's religion - at a United Nations interfaith conference in
score: 10
Washington Post 1 week ago
into effect the kind of judicial reforms that King Abdullah has announced,' said Christoph Wilcke, senior researcher on Saudi Arabia at Human Rights Watch. Al-Lahem said the award will help promote human rights in Saudi Arabia, a country under constant
score: 10
Washington Post 1 week ago
JIDDAH, Saudi Arabia, Nov. 6 -- More than 70 Saudis spent Thursday without food or water to protest the detention without trial of at least 11 dissidents. Organizers of the kingdom's
score: 10
Washington Post 2 weeks ago
JIDDAH, Saudi Arabia, Nov. 6 -- More than 70 Saudis spent Thursday without food or water to protest the detention without trial of a dozen dissidents. Organizers of the kingdom's first
score: 10
Al Jazeera 2 weeks ago
Scores of human rights activists in Saudi Arabia have started a two-day hunger strike to protest against what they term as illegal detentions in the kingdom. The protest fast, which began on Thursday, aims to highlight the
Related tags
New in General » Litigation




I lived in Saudi Arabia for a period of time...and this is a very interesting prediction question! Islamic law is the basis for civil law in that country. This adds an interesting twist that we are not familiar with in the west.
I was stunned as I read this story of abuse and realize that it seems to occur with impunity. Admittedly, I am quite ignorant of lifestyles and traditions in the east.
Lesley
Hubdub Category Manager
While we tend to think today of muslims and the Islamic faith in generic terms as one group, in fact Saudi Arabia (when I was there) had a whole CASTE SYSTEM in the Islamic culture. The Lebananese were the primary merchants, followed by the Palestinians, Syrians, Egyptians, and Saudis. (There had to be a Saudi "front man" behind every business). The Sudanese were the elegant serving class, Indonesians were much further down the totem pole, and the Yemenese basket boys in the market place were the lowest of the low. While highly illegal, Ethiopian ladies (technically coptic christian) purveyed the oldest profession. I would doubt that much has changed today.
With regard to this question, you will note that an Indonesian maid would rank fairly low on the caste system...and would be regarded as fairly unimportant...
I am truly disheartened every time I read this story. It tears at my strong belief that everybody is created equal.
@LucidStates: You are right - Humans do suck!
In 1785, Robert Burns, the Poet, coined the phrase "Man's inhumanity to man". It is still valid today.
Please log in or join to add a comment